Investigating monetary design, essential provision, ecological resilience and cooperation between communities.

CIRAS Economic Village Simulation: A Research Framework for Local and Federated Economies

Exploring monetary design, productive capacity, ecological constraints and cooperation over 10 to 200 years.

Abstract

The CIRAS Economic Village Simulation is an interactive computational model for investigating how monetary arrangements, household behaviour, productive infrastructure and natural resources jointly influence economic outcomes.

Model version 1.0.0 supports villages, cities, megacities and counties, with simulation periods of 10, 50, 100 or 200 years. An optional federation connects two to six villages through exchanges and solidarity deliveries. Users can compare monetary allocation rules, planning arrangements, ecological constraints and energy configurations under reproducible conditions.

The documentation reports both periods of relatively stable provision and substantial long-term deterioration. These results demonstrate the importance of physical resources, maintenance and specialist training within the model. They do not establish that a particular economic system would succeed or fail in practice.

All parameters remain illustrative and uncalibrated. The model is intended for hypothesis development, comparative experimentation and education.

Research questions

The project investigates a central question:

Under which institutional and material conditions can communities maintain essential provision, limit inequality and preserve ecological capacity over time?

Its experimental framework addresses:

  • The distributional effects of different money-creation rules.
  • The relationship between purchasing power and actual availability of goods.
  • The contribution of coordination, maintenance and specialist training.
  • Trade-offs between immediate provision and environmental protection.
  • The benefits and vulnerabilities of cooperation between settlements.
  • The influence of finite supplies and infrastructure deterioration on long-term outcomes.

The simulation makes these relationships explicit through adjustable assumptions and recorded monthly results.

The model economy

The standard case begins with approximately 1,000 residents. Each person receives an initial allocation of 1,000 D. Households transfer specified shares of this allocation to enterprises and the community fund, so these transfers do not create additional money.

The model contains 19 cooperatively owned firms across nine sectors: food, water, energy, housing, health and care, maintenance and construction, education, materials, and everyday goods.

Households pool monetary balances, purchase goods, supply labour and undertake unpaid care. Individuals have ages, skill categories, schooling and, where applicable, training in progress.

The community fund maintains separate budgets for provision and investment. Environmental variables include water, soil, habitat, wood, material stocks and emissions. Technical parts and medical supplies are finite initial stocks that cannot be fully reproduced locally.

The settlement uses a shared model currency without conversion into euros or dollars. The economy is closed to outside imports. Federation permits transfers between participating villages but does not create an external supply chain.

How one simulated month unfolds

The model advances through a fixed monthly sequence:

  1. Weather, disturbances and demographic changes are updated.
  2. Money is withdrawn from opening balances, followed by issuance under the selected creation rule.
  3. Basic needs, labour supply, ecological budgets and planning decisions are evaluated.
  4. Production orders, labour allocation, wages and fund contributions are processed.
  5. Enterprises produce and households receive available goods and services.
  6. Schooling, training and investment projects progress.
  7. Equipment wear, environmental conditions, prices and wages are updated.
  8. Monetary and physical balances are checked.

Production is constrained by the most restrictive input: facilities, labour, specialist skills, energy, water, materials or financing.

Consequently, additional money cannot compensate directly for missing water, unavailable medical supplies or insufficient trained personnel.

Money creation, withdrawal and distribution

The central monetary experiment gives every living person an equal entitlement to newly created money. Before rounding, the monthly allocation is:

$$[
q_t=\frac{\lambda M_t}{N_t},
]$$

where $(M_t)$ is the opening money supply, $(N_t)$ is the population and $(\lambda)$ is the creation rate.

The default rate is 1% per month. The default withdrawal rate is 0.8% of each account’s opening balance.

The model also supports four alternative allocation rules:

ModeAllocation rule
0Equal personal allocation proportional to the opening money supply
1Fixed amount per person
2Allocation according to basic needs
3Allocation to the community fund
4Allocation according to the previous month’s labour income

These alternatives allow the distribution mechanism itself to be examined.

Money withdrawn from balances is permanently deleted. Wages, purchases, inheritance and community-fund payments transfer existing money. The aggregate identity is:

$$[
M_{\text{end}}=M_{\text{start}}+\text{creation}-\text{withdrawal}.
]$$

The current model contains no loans or negative account balances. Investment must be financed from available balances.

Six experimental scenarios

ScenarioConfigurationMain research purpose
A — One-off start moneyNo continuing creation or withdrawal; planner disabled; ecological limits activeEstablish a monetary baseline
B — Creation and withdrawalPersonal issuance and balance withdrawal; planner disabledExamine ongoing monetary redistribution
C — With plannerScenario B with rule-based coordinationInvestigate planning, maintenance and training
D — Limits ignoredScenario C without ecological budget enforcementExamine provision–environment trade-offs
E — Decentralised solar housesScenario C with expanded solar generation, storage and household solar heating and coolingInvestigate distributed energy infrastructure
F — Hypothetical free energyScenario C with an assumed fuel-free, weather-independent energy sourceTest whether removing an energy constraint resolves other shortages

Scenario F is a thought experiment. The documentation explicitly states that the assumed “overunity” technology is not yet official confirmed by physics. Its inclusion does not constitute a technology claim.

Comparisons must account for all changed settings. In particular, A and B differ in both creation and withdrawal, while E changes several energy-related parameters.

Planning under imperfect information

The built-in planner is a disclosed rule set, described in the documentation as an “AI surrogate.” It prioritises protective limits, basic provision, failure prevention and additional benefits with limited resource use.

Its decisions include investment proposals, maintenance priorities, allocation of scarce labour and training ahead of expected retirements.

The planner does not have perfect information. Default assumptions include 80% data coverage, 5% measurement error and a two-month delay. It receives no future information.

The documentation separately describes an optional external AI planner. That feature was not exercised for the documented results; those results should therefore not be presented as evidence of external AI performance.

Federation: cooperation between villages

Federation is implemented as an optional arrangement of two to six villages. Each village remains a complete simulation with its own weather and slightly different initial resources. Scheduled disturbances affect participating villages in turn.

After each month, the federation redistributes selected resources:

  • Food and materials move through paid exchanges or solidarity deliveries.
  • Solidarity delivery can support a village that cannot pay.
  • Technical parts and medical supplies are shared as common resources.
  • Deliveries incur a configurable transport loss, defaulting to 5%.

Payments move money between villages without changing the federation’s total money supply.

The documentation reports a ten-year example with three villages of 1,000 residents. Across the run, 12,587 food rations and 14,876 D moved between villages. The average share of residents with all basic needs met was 56%, with village-level averages of 54%, 39% and 75%.

This example demonstrates the implemented exchange mechanism and substantial differences between participating communities. Without an otherwise matched non-sharing comparison, it does not establish the size of federation’s benefit.

Sharing also cannot replenish a resource that the federation cannot produce. It can redistribute finite medical and technical supplies, but their aggregate scarcity remains.

Settlement types and scale

Four settlement presets are available:

SettlementRepresentation
VillageStandard local economy, normally around 1,000 residents
CityScaled population with different infrastructure and resource assumptions
MegacityA larger extrapolated population represented by a smaller simulated sample
CountyA federation of one town and three villages

Up to 5,000 residents can be represented individually. Larger populations use scaling: each simulated person represents multiple people, and aggregate quantities are extrapolated.

The documented megacity configuration represents approximately five million people using 2,500 simulated individuals.

These are scaled experiments, not detailed urban models. Congestion, land-price dynamics and specialised industrial systems are not represented. Differences between presets also reflect different starting resources and infrastructure, rather than population scale alone.

What the documented experiments show

The documentation reports the following ten-year results for a village starting with 1,000 residents, seed 2026 and the standard event schedule:

ScenarioAverage share with all basic needs metMean coverage of the worst-off tenthGini of balances at the end
A — One-off start money58%96%0.52
B — Creation and withdrawal48%95%0.46
C — With planner57%96%0.53
D — Limits ignored86%100%0.48

These are individual simulated trajectories, not empirical estimates or statistically established rankings.

Scenario B produces a lower end-of-run balance inequality than A, but lower average complete-needs coverage in this experiment. Scenario C improves provision relative to B without achieving the lowest inequality.

Scenario D delivers higher early provision while repeatedly exceeding environmental limits. During the ten-year run, wood extraction exceeds its limit in 108 months, habitat protection in 99 months and soil protection in 42 months.

The model therefore exposes trade-offs that would be obscured by a single aggregate success score.

Long-term outcomes: maintenance and finite supplies

The fifty-year experiments show why short-term performance is insufficient.

Under the documented assumptions, medical supplies are exhausted around years 30–32 and technical parts around years 36–39 in the baseline comparisons. These shortages reduce healthcare effectiveness and undermine maintenance.

The strict “all basic needs met” indicator then falls sharply. This does not mean that every service disappears: the indicator requires each person to reach at least 95% coverage in every essential category.

Planning materially changes the remaining provision in these runs. In Scenario C, mean coverage of the worst-off tenth remains 66% during years 41–50, compared with 9% in Scenario B. The documentation attributes this difference partly to earlier specialist training and better coordination.

Scenario E illustrates another trade-off. Expanded decentralised solar provision removes the documented crisis months over fifty years, but technical parts are exhausted earlier around year 31 rather than year 37 in Scenario C.

These outcomes are consequences of the stated assumptions, particularly limited local replacement capacity and the absence of outside imports.

Connections to CIRAS research programmes

The simulation can provide an experimental setting for questions arising from existing CIRAS initiatives. The documentation does not establish technical integration with these programmes.

ProgrammePotential research connection
Parisii QFS–CIRAS cooperationTransaction records, settlement processes and accountability in inter-community exchange
Contract-Centric Public Finance LabExplicit infrastructure obligations and future contract-based financing modules
Web B(eyond)Evidence-linked representations of assets, resources and measured conditions
CIRAS–HYVEN programmeIndependently validated energy, storage, construction and infrastructure parameters
One Light Human EconomyParticipatory evaluation of allocation, cooperation and community governance

A productive next step would be to replace selected illustrative assumptions with independently measured data and evaluate whether the model reproduces observed patterns.

Adding credit or contractual finance would require new accounting structures for claims, liabilities, repayment and default. Such mechanisms are not part of the current debt-free model.

Image Not Found

How readers can use the simulation

1. Open the application and establish a baseline

Begin with a village of 1,000 residents, seed 2026 and a ten-year horizon. Record the selected scenario and any changes.

Use Start to observe the run or Run to end to calculate the selected period. Consult the application’s User guide for detailed controls.

2. Inspect several dimensions of performance

Review provision and resources alongside money:

ViewQuestions to investigate
MoneyHow do balances, prices, purchasing power and inequality change?
SupplyWhich essential needs remain unmet?
NatureWhich stocks decline or ecological limits are exceeded?
InvestmentAre projects completed and facilities maintained?
ComparisonWhich settings explain differences between runs?
ChecksAre accounting and physical balances internally consistent?

A low price index does not establish that goods are available. A large monetary balance does not establish that a household’s needs are met.

3. Compare one mechanism at a time

Keep the seed and relevant starting conditions constant. Compare B with C to investigate the planner, or C with D to examine ecological enforcement.

Use the money-creation modes to investigate distribution separately from other policy changes.

The engine separates random streams so that changing policy does not itself change the weather sequence.

4. Run a federation experiment

In Settings, enable federation and select between two and six villages. The population setting applies per village. Restart after changing federation membership.

Begin with three villages and the default transport loss. Compare solidarity delivery enabled and disabled while holding other settings constant.

Evaluate every village as well as the aggregate. Record shortages, transfers, reserve depletion and persistent differences in provision.

5. Test disturbances and longer horizons

Introduce or modify droughts, crop failures, energy outages, illness waves or delayed investment.

After examining ten-year behaviour, extend the analysis to 50, 100 or 200 years. Investigate how maintenance, specialist replacement and finite supplies change the interpretation.

6. Examine variability

Repeat experiments across seeds and use the comparison and sensitivity tools. In the documentation’s ten-seed sample for Scenario B, average complete-needs coverage ranges from 41% to 62%.

Automatic search identifies favourable configurations within a limited sample. It does not prove optimality.

7. Export and document results

Export JSON to preserve settings, seed, model version, initial state, events, changes and monthly data. CSV provides a monthly overview for spreadsheet analysis.

Record the research question, comparator, assumptions and outcome measures. On import, the application recomputes the run and checks it against the exported results.

Verification, limitations and research value

The documentation reports ten passing model checks covering monetary accounting, solvency, unit invariance, physical balances, production constraints, financing, zero issuance, reproducibility, disturbances and invalid-data handling.

These checks establish internal consistency. They do not establish empirical validity.

The principal limitations are uncalibrated coefficients, simplified behaviour, few uniform firms, coarse monthly processes, simple federation rules and scaled representations of large populations.

The model’s research value lies in exposing those assumptions and allowing their consequences to be examined. Its documented results make clear that monetary design, ecological protection, infrastructure maintenance and cooperation must be assessed together and over sufficiently long periods to reveal dependencies that short experiments can miss.

Technical basis: Village Simulation documentation, model version 1.0.0, particularly Chapters 4, 7–8 and 10–13. Numerical results above are reported from that document; they are not newly computed experiments.


New Report

Close

Enable Notifications OK No thanks